Milwaukee Wings

The Original Guide to Buffalo Wings in the Brew City

In Cahoots & Co. (70)

The Vitals:

Name: In Cahoots & Co.
Where: S43 W31325 Hwy 83, Genesee Depot, WI 53127
Review Date: Saturday, April 13, 2010
Wing type: Traditional Bone-in
Wing Special: $0.25 Wings Tuesday & Thursday, 11a-2p & 5p-9p

The Review:

  • Chicken Quality: Pretty small wings, a group of six of us smoked 120 wings without too much trouble.  I few of the wings were really tiny.  Cooked well, the wings had a nice crispness to them which I enjoy.  However, due to their size some of them got a bit over done and dried out.  However, most of the wings retained some moistness to them and were quite good.
  • Sauce Variety: Three flavors to choose from: Hot, Mild, and BBQ.  Plain is also an option.
  • Sauce Quality:
    • Mild – Very standard Buffalo wing flavor with a sauce based on a cayenne pepper hot sauce.  Nothing unique, but a great classic buffalo wing taste with just a good amount of heat.
    • Hot – Very similar to the mild, just hotter.  Sadly, it really wasn’t too much hotter, I actually had difficulty telling the difference between the hot and mild wings.  Nevertheless, classic Buffalo wing flavor that I love
    • BBQ – A sweet tangy BBQ sauce.  I prefer a bit more bite in my BBQ, so I wasn’t much of a fan of this.
    • Sauces overall – Definitely not a lot of variety, but the hot and mild were the classic Buffalo wing flavor that I love, so I can’t complain.
  • Sides Quality: Bleu cheese, ranch, and celery were all served with the wings.  Bleu cheese had a bit of a sour taste to it but not terribly noticeable, but all sides compliment the wings well.
  • Value: Having two $0.25 wing specials in one week is a great deal in my book!



The Final Score:

Chicken Quality: 7/10
Sauce Quality: 8/10
Sauce Variety: 2/5
Sides Quality: 3/5
Value: 3/3

Overall: 23/33 = 70

Unless you’re live nearby or are passing through the area, In Cahoots probably isn’t a place worth taking a journey to just for wings.  However, if you are in the area, In Cahoots is definitely a good spot for some decent wings at a good price.

1 Comment

Add a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Milwaukee Wings, 2018